Let's Not Enable TNT in Regions

[MultiHeartGold]

Also, would destroying a cannon attacking your town be considered griefing since it is a player owned structure/item ?

If its over 100 blocks from the town, Im sure it would count as griefing. But if they are forced to shoot from 100 blocks away from your walls (assuming you use your whole regions), they probably wont reach much in, meaning your chests will most likely be safe. You could also make your own TNT cannons as a part of your town defense and shoot those.

 

[Xargun]

Of course it wouldnt be griefing its clearly a temp structure, like a pillar and should be treated as such, prone to being removed...

So if the raiders don't remove it then you can pe them for griefing ? Sounds a bit ridiculous.

 

[Sidgil]

TNT should be enabled, so I can watch the world burn. *puts on evil mustache*

 

[Xargun]

TNT should be enabled, so I can watch the world burn. *puts on evil mustache*

Fire doesn't spread

 

[Predator2010]

So if the raiders don't remove it then you can pe them for griefing ? Sounds a bit ridiculous.

Of course, as soon as they create it to obtain access it becomes their problem, so they should remove it as they enter like most players do with pillars, its simple not ridiculous, just takes common sense.

 

[Predator2010]

TNT should be enabled, so I can watch the world burn. *puts on evil mustache*

Im just disappointed Sidgil :'(

 

[Xargun]

If its over 100 blocks from the town, Im sure it would count as griefing. But if they are forced to shoot from 100 blocks away from your walls (assuming you use your whole regions), they probably wont reach much in, meaning your chests will most likely be safe. You could also make your own TNT cannons as a part of your town defense and shoot those.

You know they will put the cannons as close to the town / target as possible so without a min range they will be blasting our walls from 5-10 blocks away without kingdom regions. So figure they blow the wall in the first shot and other buildings with the second / third... Depends on how many cannons they build.

 

[Predator2010]

You know they will put the cannons as close to the town / target as possible so without a min range they will be blasting our walls from 5-10 blocks away without kingdom regions. So figure they blow the wall in the first shot and other buildings with the second / third... Depends on how many cannons they build.

They would need to have extreme amounts of skill in order to shoot a second or third cannon through the original hole in the wall created by the first cannon to destroy buildings....

 

[MultiHeartGold]

You know they will put the cannons as close to the town / target as possible so without a min range they will be blasting our walls from 5-10 blocks away without kingdom regions. So figure they blow the wall in the first shot and other buildings with the second / third... Depends on how many cannons they build.

If they keep a cannon within 5-10 blocks from town, they have to make sure they remove it before any of the town's defenders are able to kill them, or else it will count as griefing (or whatever you would call breaking the "no builds within 100 blocks" rule.)

 

[MajorasMask]

Delfofthebla How long will the TNT ''hole'' last before it regenerates?

 

[Myaras]

Please dont quote people and comment with a useless statement, if you cant or wont answer the question dont quote that post

Serious question (not trying to be snarky)...should I show my support for the question by rating it with one of the cute little icons available? Essentially I was trying to "second the motion." If I'm wrong, I apologize.

So as not to hijack the thread, I agree with your latest post, Predator2010, regarding it being a temp structure.

 

[Predator2010]

Serious question (not trying to be snarky)...should I show my support for the question by rating it with one of the cute little icons available? Essentially I was trying to "second the motion." If I'm wrong, I apologize.

So as not to hijack the thread, I agree with your latest post, Predator2010, regarding it being a temp structure.

Yes, supporting a question can be represented with the little emoticons in the corner of a post Myras
-
And Im not sure as i said before but i believe around 5 seconds for the hole in the wall

 

[Delfofthebla]

Delfofthebla How long will the TNT ''hole'' last before it regenerates?

I don't know the exact duration at the moment. It seems to be longer when successive TNT explosions occur, and I'm not sure if that's intentional or not.

I've seen an explosion regenerate over 2 minutes, but I've also seen it take around 2 hours. The extended duration is likely a bug, but I can't say for sure.

 

[Sirdemonic3]

I don't know the exact duration at the moment. It seems to be longer when successive TNT explosions occur, and I'm not sure if that's intentional or not.

I've seen an explosion regenerate over 2 minutes, but I've also seen it take around 2 hours. The extended duration is likely a bug, but I can't say for sure.

i blow up alot of stuff in test so im sure u get ample material to test on

 

[Predator2010]

I don't know the exact duration at the moment. It seems to be longer when successive TNT explosions occur, and I'm not sure if that's intentional or not.

I've seen an explosion regenerate over 2 minutes, but I've also seen it take around 2 hours. The extended duration is likely a bug, but I can't say for sure.

Hahahaha, a hole for two hours long :< that was be... horrific :'(
Keep up the good work delf <3

 

[Dielan9999]

Also, would destroying a cannon attacking your town be considered griefing since it is a player owned structure/item ?

Kainzo

Thoughts on this? I think it should be legal. Why attack the enemy camp if you aren't allowed to break the siege weaponry?

 

[Kainzo]

Kainzo

Thoughts on this? I think it should be legal. Why attack the enemy camp if you aren't allowed to break the siege weaponry?

Cannons would be exempt from the grief rule.

 

[KleenX]

Are people seriously complaining they can't sit inside their impenetrable towns? Stop acting like your going to lose your "beautiful" structures to not get this implemented. If you cannot properly defend your town, then it is completely your fault. You make a town knowing fully that you could be breached at any time under any circumstances. Just because "I don't like PVP" doesn't mean you get a free pass. This is a hardcore server AND an RPG server. I know that RPG doesn't necessarily mean RP but I think your role should always be a merchant/builder when you are not in danger but then when duty calls you will fight because you have to. NOT LIKING PVP IS NOT AN EXCUSE.
MajorasMask
Your region will regen. Stop acting like it will be blown to bits and you will have no region. If your region is getting blown up don't you think you have a duty to defend it?

 

[Predator2010]

Cannons would be exempt from the grief rule.

As i said earlier they would be treated such as pillars, prone to destruction by all players, raiders or defenders
But thankyou for the clarification kainzo

 

[Dielan9999]

Are people seriously complaining they can't sit inside their impenetrable towns? Stop acting like your going to lose your "beautiful" structures to not get this implemented. If you cannot properly defend your town, then it is completely your fault. You make a town knowing fully that you could be breached at any time under any circumstances. Just because "I don't like PVP" doesn't mean you get a free pass. This is a hardcore server AND an RPG server. I know that RPG doesn't necessarily mean RP but I think your role should always be a merchant/builder when you are not in danger but then when duty calls you will fight because you have to. NOT LIKING PVP IS NOT AN EXCUSE.
MajorasMask
Your region will regen. Stop acting like it will be blown to bits and you will have no region. If your region is getting blown up don't you think you have a duty to defend it?

Actually towns are created for the intention to protect you. They still will, it is just that now they are easier to penetrate, harder to defend. Encouraging strong and wealthy towns, as the weak will now die off. It's not impossible to keep your town from being affected by cannons, and it doesn't have to look bad either.