Suggestion [RULES] Reinstate the Illegality of Griefing Plants

[Howdanrocks]

Plants were made a griefable block in Zeal and since then, its just been a nuisance. Going and breaking another player's farm without replanting is no different than destroying their house. I really don't understand why it was made legal in the first place, but I would like to see it be made illegal once more.

Thank you for your consideration,
Howdanrocks

 

[Iarbobray]

In my opinion, it should only be legal if they replant. Like, they can run in, steal your wheat, but they have to replant. If not, it's griefing. Making just stealing plants in general even if you replant isn't that great of an idea.

 

[Howdanrocks]

In my opinion, it should only be legal if they replant. Like, they can run in, steal your wheat, but they have to replant. If not, it's griefing. Making just stealing plants in general even if you replant isn't that great of an idea.

I said "breaking another player's farm without replanting is...". So yea, I agree.

 

[Angyles]

I like the idea of having to replant.

 

[Ostadar]

I don't see why it shouldn't be made so they have to replant. It just assures that when you go back again that there will be more that you can take and you still leave with the spoils of the crop as well, just this way there will be a few less seeds cluttering the inventory or needing to be incinerated.

 

[Kainzo]

Admins want to weigh in?
@Alator
@bearcat99
@BuddahHopper
@Brutalacerate
I'm fine with the rule change, it will have to be pushed to a week+ and changed on the wiki - would like to know what the other admins think.

 

[kevinlive]

This would be great, can't say I'm a fan of raiders running into your farms, breaking everything, and then running off while laughing their asses off.

 

[Alator]

Hmm. I personally hated when people would come in and ruin my plants, heh. I'd say this:

The only thing really worth taking from a player is food. I think the best way to word this would be "Plants must be left in a position where they will regrow to their original state." This means people will have to replant wheat, and will not be able to take plants stems, flowers, the bottom block of reeds, and for the most part trees.

Thoughts?

 

[Angyles]

Hmm. I personally hated when people would come in and ruin my plants, heh. I'd say this:

The only thing really worth taking from a player is food. I think the best way to word this would be "Plants must be left in a position where they will regrow to their original state." This means people will have to replant wheat, and will not be able to take plants stems, flowers, the bottom block of reeds, and for the most part trees.

Thoughts?

Do not forget cactus =D

 

[Kainzo]

Hmm. I personally hated when people would come in and ruin my plants, heh. I'd say this:

The only thing really worth taking from a player is food. I think the best way to word this would be "Plants must be left in a position where they will regrow to their original state." This means people will have to replant wheat, and will not be able to take plants stems, flowers, the bottom block of reeds, and for the most part trees.

Thoughts?

Yah, I'm fine with that, mark it to become a law on 10/1 ... and HOLY CRAP ... 2 years of Herocraft is coming in 7 days!

 

[kevinlive]

Yah, I'm fine with that, mark it to become a law on 10/1 ... and HOLY CRAP ... 2 years of Herocraft is coming in 7 days!

Wow, wasn't the 1 year anniversary just recent? o.o
My god, time flies fast.

 

[Angyles]

Yah, I'm fine with that, mark it to become a law on 10/1 ... and HOLY CRAP ... 2 years of Herocraft is coming in 7 days!

Woohoo! May we please have an epic event to mark the occasion? =D

 

[macura]

i dont wanna replant stuff

 

[whitemagehealu]

i dont wanna replant stuff

Then don't destroy it. Simple.

 

[bearcat99]

I'm ok with it.

 

[Alator]

Yah, I'm fine with that, mark it to become a law on 10/1 ... and HOLY CRAP ... 2 years of Herocraft is coming in 7 days!

Updated, and holy crap 2 years!

 

[Dsawemd]

If we really care about non-regioned farms, then do this. But I think lore doesn't need this rule change. Its a plant, rip it out of the ground if you want to.
And it will cause a lot of chatter in-game about griefing farms, I remember that from zeal.

Do farmers need it? Maybe.

 

[bearcat99]

Dsa brings up a good point. Maybe stopping leaf block/tree/lilly pad griefing, but stomping on wheat is like cutting off the food supplies. If you want to hurt your enemy, you cut off or weaken their food.

PROTECT YOUR WHEAT!

 

[Fo0l3d]

This update is completely illogical... why, are people too lazy to replant their farms?

 

[Howdanrocks]

This update is completely illogical... why, are people too lazy to replant their farms?

Its not too easy to replant if you don't have much of the plant that is being griefed in the first place.