Suggestion [Rule Change] Greifing

[awsumguy75321]

I do not see a road falling under this criteria. It does not reduce accessibility, nor does it block a view.

So by your suggestion, a road should be exempt from this "rule" change?

I am trying not to be in this argument. However, you brought up roads. For example, if player A has a wonderful view of mountains/plains/etc. from his window a block off of the ground, and player B makes a road from point A to point B a block off of the ground a few blocks away from the window, that would block the view. If a road blocks off a waterfall that a player often uses to climb up a mountain to his house, it would reduce accessibility. It would be hard for a road to fit this criteria, yes, but not impossible.

 

[Danda]

They must be allowed to remove it by the town, else-wise they are exempt from their responsibility to remove the pillar.

A problem I have seen with this in the past is that players will "come to remove a pillar" then attack town members and claim that they were killed thus they don't need to remove the pillar anymore. This can't always be proven and can boil down to a huge he said she said argument.

 

[donaldmax1]

Idea time! How about a command for all whitelisted players that rolls back dirt and cobble stone structures in the last 30 min or more or less. Also you must be in 100 block range to use the command on the dirt/cobblestone structure.

 

[Alator]

A problem I have seen with this in the past is that players will "come to remove a pillar" then attack town members and claim that they were killed thus they don't need to remove the pillar anymore. This can't always be proven and can boil down to a huge he said she said argument.

There's no easy way to go about this that one party or the other can't try to exploit. If they have to remove it no matter what, the town can just keep killing them until they give up and then put in a PE. If they don't have to remove it, then people will just spam pillars around towns claiming they were just trying to get in.

 

[EvilThor]

A problem I have seen with this in the past is that players will "come to remove a pillar" then attack town members and claim that they were killed thus they don't need to remove the pillar anymore. This can't always be proven and can boil down to a huge he said she said argument.

I think I remember a saying from zeal..
Wasn't is: "fraps it or it didn't happened"?

I know that this is not a good solution and it's really annoying, but for reasons like that do I always got recording software ready in background.

 

[Keache]

I think I remember a saying from zeal..
Wasn't is: "fraps it or it didn't happened"?

I know that this is not a good solution and it's really annoying, but for reasons like that do I always got recording software ready in background.

Unfortunately not everyone has te recording space nor money to blow on a shitty recording software such as fraps...

That's why I pirated it.

 

[arcanegrove]

Having land proportional to the structure should be in. Let's say, a 15x15 house gets 15 blocks of land,. If H=House, and L=Land, the we can come up with decent area for larger structures. L=H*0.75 if H is greater the or equal to 30. this would give a 100x100 castle 75 blocks of land. I think this is a reasonable amount of land to structure size ratio. I was thinking of making it 1/2 but that didn't seem like enough to me.

 

[what777]

Tip: Use dxtory instead of fraps, way better frame rate. (Harder to configure though)

 

[EvilThor]

Unfortunately not everyone has te recording space nor money to blow on a shitty recording software such as fraps...

That's why I pirated it.

Since when did you need either a legal or pro-verson of a recording software to prove someone is doing something illegal?

And the software itself don't take up much space, what takes space is raw film (not compiled), but you don't need to keep those for the next year..

 

[awsumguy75321]

Since when did you need either a legal or pro-verson of a recording software to prove someone is doing something illegal?

And the software itself don't take up much space, what takes space is raw film (not compiled), but you don't need to keep those for the next year..

Why would you even need recording software? You can record it from a phone or something like that!