Suggestion Meeting Speak Permissions

[lhatchy1]

So, as it stands, people who are t6+, Mayors or Staff can talk during the meeting main segment.

I just feel it to be illogical that people who are elite/veteran can't talk, but people who have donated enough can.

@Kainzo tagging cos' of late notice.

I just feel like I've been here a long time, but because I didn't donate enough I can't speak during the main meeting segment, even though I've been here for 2 1/2 years.

Thoughts?

 

[Azzezima]

I think that anyone that played this game for a year and doesn't have a bad reputation should be able to speak.

-Azzezima-

 

[Evanist]

Agreed to that... Kinda makes it that those who are staying true to herocraft would have at least the feeling of being accepted

 

[Jonsoon]

So, as it stands, people who are t6+, Mayors or Staff can talk during the meeting main segment.

I just feel it to be illogical that people who are elite/veteran can't talk, but people who have donated enough can.

@Kainzo tagging cos' of late notice.

I just feel like I've been here a long time, but because I didn't donate enough I can't speak during the main meeting segment, even though I've been here for 2 1/2 years.

Thoughts?

It has little to do with keeping non donors out. Could you imagine 100 people all having speak perms in a single TS channel? That is why the restriction is in place.

 

[devotedworker]

it seems illogical to block out a large portion of the comunity for a " Comunity Meeting ", but I can see where it would be required to restrict the number of users talking at the same time, but there are much better ways of going around this. Maybe have each user submit 1-2 questions before the chat and during the chat have the Staff discuss the good questions with other staff members. The doners could still talk as they did in this meeting, but atleast all the users would have an influence on the topics at hand

I really wanted to ask some good questions! XD ( Though most of them got answered anyway T_T )

 

[Jonsoon]

it seems illogical to block out a large portion of the comunity for a " Comunity Meeting ", but I can see where it would be required to restrict the number of users talking at the same time, but there are much better ways of going around this. Maybe have each user submit 1-2 questions before the chat and during the chat have the Staff discuss the good questions with other staff members. The doners could still talk as they did in this meeting, but atleast all the users would have an influence on the topics at hand

I really wanted to ask some good questions! XD ( Though most of them got answered anyway T_T )

You mean the thread where Kainzo announced the meeting and asked people for topics they would talk about?
http://herocraftonline.com/main/threads/community-meeting-03-15-14-3pm-cst.50393/

 

[devotedworker]

Sorta like that, but maybe it be a tad more organized and well suited. As far as I was aware till you mentioned it, I was not aware that was a discussion going on XD ( Picking your questions and such ) ( This was probably my own fault for not noticing it XD )

But in either case, even with the "Not Allowing regular people to talk" I still was satisfied with the discussions held during the meeting, not to look as though I am utterly disgusted with the meeting. It was good

 

[Fjordsen]

I think that anyone that played this game for a year and doesn't have a bad reputation should be able to speak.-

So they should judge every single person that joins the meeting wether their reputation is good enough or not? That would take such a long time.

 

[Air_Restraint]

I really agree with this. It's kinda stupid in my opinion. Someone that just joined could pay for tier 6 and put in their opinion about a server they aren't familiar with. It kinda sucked just watching the meeting and not speaking when I have played for close to 2 years. But it is Kainzo's decision. If he wants it that way then we will have to deal with it.