The thread has devolved to personal insults, repeating the same thing, and Lumify being wrecked like a ship trying to dock a coast at midnight, with no lighthouse. The only discussions I see are people trying to tell Lumify how Herocraft works, and him whining about HC not being exactly like other mmo's, where a team of professionals set everything in stone first, and then add content updates. With HC, it's constantly being reworked. Total overhauls to mechanics are a constant. And I find that amazing about the server. There is always something new or exciting, some new update, a new way the game works, classes have been fixed/changed. But that's not what is being discussed. Here we have would could have been an interesting, and possibly enlightening thread. However, it was created by the wrong person, and flooded with half-baked ideals that come from playing a class for a small amount of time, and hearsay. Classes are balanced for their role in PvP, and some can make it dungeon easily. That's just how the class plays. The rest are all balanced for their role in PvP, but with constant dungeon changed it is impossible to balance it in PvE as well, without fucking the PvP balances. Not to mention the dungeon is designed to be played with a party, so using "ranger can work in T6 no problem" as your argument is like saying, "This class that hasn't been reformed to the new dungeon changed is op in pve and every class I like should be like that, because I want to instantly play the class I like easily." To restate my point, close this thread. It can only go downhill from here.
I think we have an understanding. For this list, as the majority of combat gameplay happens in dungeons, I based class viability on dungeon viability. This is what new players experience upon joining the server, and picking a bad class because someone said "they're all balanced" is going to deter people from playing Herocraft. The only person who could make a thread like this and not get insulted and spammed is an admin, but that's not going to happen because they don't want to make an official statement on something they still have to fix but aren't going to for the foreseeable future.
But yeah, this thread is absolute crap. I was trying to have a decent conversation, but people charge in here with emotional baggage, which, if anything, proves the validity of the class balance problems.