My oh my, where to begin... You say Sare is being untruthful? Well, you speak so much of proof, so where's yours? Sare has logblock, as well as witnesses to your behavior. On top of that, what reason would he have for lying? As a mayor he can kick you for any reason, he wouldn't need to make something up, nor would he bother to have you blacklisted if all he wanted to do is get rid of ya.
Next up, taking the whole house would have been obvious griefing and you know you'd be caught and rolled back. So you could take small things and leave without getting caught, or so you thought.
And the 40c is easy. Maybe you spent it. Maybe a friend is holding it. Maybe you didn't bother to get paid up front. Countless possibilities.
You're welcome to come try and raid us. We'll be waiting eagerly.